When it comes to selling your home, pricing isn’t just about numbers – it’s about psychology. Setting the right price is one of the most powerful home pricing strategies you can use to attract buyers, spark competition, and ultimately maximize your return. Yet, many sellers make a common mistake: pricing their home at a neat, round number like $900,000 or $1,000,000.
While round numbers may feel clean and straightforward, they can actually hurt your sale. Why? Because buyers don’t shop with emotion alone; they also search within very specific price ranges. Let’s break down the psychology of pricing and why you may want to rethink how to price your home in Oshawa or anywhere in Durham Region.
Why Pricing Matters More Than You Think
The price you set for your home is the first impression buyers see. Before they even step foot inside, the price tag signals the value, competition, and desirability of your property. Homes that are strategically priced tend to sell faster and closer to the asking price compared to homes priced too high from the start.
Think of it this way: price your home wrong, and you’ll either turn off potential buyers or leave money on the table. Get it right, and you’ll not only attract more offers, but you might even spark a bidding war.
The Problem with Round Numbers
Many sellers believe that pricing a home at $900,000 looks straightforward and appealing. But here’s the issue: most buyers search online using price brackets. For example:
- A buyer looking between $850,000 and $899,999 will never see your $900,000 listing.
- Similarly, someone searching between $900,000 and $950,000 will see your home, but it’s competing against larger, potentially more luxurious properties in that higher range.
This means your perfectly round $900,000 listing actually reduces visibility and puts you in competition with the wrong group of buyers.
By contrast, if you priced at $899,900, you capture buyers searching under $900,000 and those searching at $900,000 and up. That extra visibility could be the difference between a quick sale and a stale listing.
The Power of Psychological Pricing
Psychological pricing is a strategy widely used in retail and it applies to real estate pricing too. We’ve all seen items priced at $9.99 instead of $10 – that’s not an accident. Shoppers perceive $9.99 as a better deal, even though it’s just one cent less.
In real estate, the same principle applies. Homes priced at $899,900 appear more competitive and attract more buyers than homes priced at $900,000. It’s not deception – it’s strategy. The goal is to position your property where the maximum number of buyers will see it.
Home Pricing Strategies That Work
If you’re wondering how to price your home in Oshawa or the wider Durham Region, here are proven strategies that go beyond round numbers:
1. Price Just Below the Threshold
Instead of listing at $900,000, price at $899,900. This keeps your property visible in two major buyer brackets and makes your home appear more competitive.
2. Consider Market Momentum
In a seller’s market, pricing slightly below market value can generate multiple offers and drive the price higher. In a buyer’s market, pricing competitively ensures your listing doesn’t sit too long.
3. Use Local Comparables (Comps)
Analyzing similar homes in your neighborhood is critical. If homes on your street have recently sold for $875,000, listing at $950,000 will likely scare off buyers. Instead, work with a professional who can provide a home worth evaluation based on local data.
4. Understand Buyer Psychology
Buyers often set “mental budgets.” Someone approved for $900,000 won’t bother looking at homes listed at $905,000. Pricing just below their ceiling can keep your property within reach.
5. Round Strategically When It Makes Sense
Sometimes, round pricing does work – for example, if you’re intentionally targeting buyers searching in a specific luxury range (like $1,500,000+). But for the majority of Oshawa listings, strategic pricing just below thresholds will increase visibility.
Local Insights: Oshawa and Durham Region
In Durham, affordability compared to Toronto continues to attract buyers, especially first-time homeowners and young families. For this reason, precision in pricing is even more important.
A family searching for a detached home in Oshawa may filter their online search between $750,000–$800,000. If you’ve priced your home at $805,000 because it “sounds nice,” you risk being completely invisible to that buyer pool.
By contrast, a listing at $799,900 lands squarely in front of the right audience. This subtle difference could drastically improve your showing traffic and offer potential.
If you’d like to see how your property compares, browsing Durham Region listings is an excellent way to understand where your home sits in the local market.
The Role of Professional Marketing
Of course, pricing is only one piece of the puzzle. Even the best-priced home won’t sell quickly without effective marketing. At Bold Group, we combine home pricing strategies with professional staging, photography, and targeted marketing to ensure maximum exposure.
When pricing and marketing work hand-in-hand, sellers can often achieve stronger results in less time.
Common Pricing Mistakes to Avoid
-
Overpricing to Leave “Negotiation Room”
Buyers today are well-informed. Overpricing typically reduces interest and forces sellers to lower their price later – often below what they could have achieved by pricing correctly from the start.
-
Relying on Emotion
Sellers sometimes overvalue their homes because of personal attachment. While understandable, buyers won’t pay extra for sentimental value.
-
Ignoring Market Shifts
A strategy that worked six months ago may not work today. Interest rates, inventory, and demand all shift quickly. Regularly reviewing data with a trusted advisor helps avoid missteps.
Figuring out how much your home might be worth in Durham is a key step in avoiding these common pricing mistakes, since understanding your property’s true value helps you set a strategy that attracts the right buyers.
Taking the Next Step
If you’re still wondering how to price your home in Durham, the best next step is a personalized consultation. An experienced real estate team can evaluate your property, review local comps, and create a strategy tailored to today’s market conditions.
You can start with our free home worth tool or book a seller’s consultation to receive a professional valuation.
Final Thoughts
The psychology of pricing is a powerful yet often overlooked part of selling a home. While round numbers may feel natural, they can limit your visibility and cost you thousands in missed opportunities. Instead, adopting smart home pricing strategies – such as pricing just below key thresholds – will position your property for success.
At Bold Group, we help Oshawa and Durham homeowners unlock the full potential of their properties with data-driven strategies and proven marketing techniques. If you’re preparing to sell, the right pricing plan could be the key to achieving your best possible result.